Just put yourself in Karnas position. Still he was about to help draupadi....if krishna was even a moment late, karna would've killed Dushashan. Draupadi Cheer Haran, Lord Krishana did not save Draupadi from Cheer Haran. They do not want to mess with it for the sake of authenticity. The living example is all says Bhisma, Drona and Karna were on Adharma side because they had lost and killed. What Karna did was right. Latter you came to know that woman who rejected you became the wife of five husbands... How you will feel. Duryodhana used him against the Pandavas and made him the king of Anga though he knew that he was a Suta putra. Etiquettes - those are what form the protocols of warfare. Karna was already killed 5 times before; you just finished off an already dying prey".1) When Indra asked for his armour2) When Kunti asked for the wish of Karna not killing anyone else but Arjuna3) When Parasuram cursed karna that he will forget the mantras to invoke astras4) When a sage cursed him that his chariot will be stuck in mud and his charioteer abandoned him at that juncture.5)When Krishna disguised as a brahmana asks for Karna's punyas (good deeds) as a gift - this is because Karna will not die on the battlefield because Lady Dharma will be protecting him from all harm/that mortal shot from Arjuna's bow - karna becomes impenetrable at that point and therefore unconquerable - Krishna takes away that from him and then Karna is killed.Now the interesting point to note here is:When Karna is almost dead/dying - Krishna is so pleased with Karna because even at that point, he did not refuse to donate - as far as Karna was concerned nothing belonged to him - Austerity - that is the foremost principle which a brahman should adhere to.So when Krishna asked Karna for his wishes, Karna's wishes were:1) When he dies on the battlefield, his real mother (kunti) should be informed and she should cry for his death for the whole world to hear his true heritage/lineage - he was denied this opportunity in life, at least let it be granted in death.2)If because of his orientation on the battle (alignment with the Kauravas), he is to suffer the process of rebirth - he wanted to be born as a brahman in a worthy family - the reasoning was, that the one thing that he could not do when he was Karna was provide Anna Dhaana - giving away food to the poor - because people did not want to eat the food fed by a person of questionable lineage.The most impressive part in this is, that when people are dying - they usually wish for either a protraction of life or for easing of suffering and the irony is that Karna asked for those just as any other person would do: He wanted to ease his suffering (not from wounds) but from shame he had to go through all his life of being a son of a charioteer and he wanted a continuation in life so that he can do the one thing that was denied to him in his previous birth - The ability to donate food.Karna was the only person to whom Krishna revealed one of his many forms - the form where he sits on Garuda!Karna was indestructible - and therefore had to be "put down" in an indirect way - if not for all other stories in Mahabharatha - one of them should suffice:Arjuna and Karna were engaged in a mon-a-mono combat and Arjuna hit Karna's chariot with an arrow, which dislodged karna's chariot by a hundred paces. Okay .. It can be for material pleasure or name or can be for enjoying a higher seat after death. If he does then, is he failed in the task? In early days (Mahabharatha time) it was not uncommon to praise the opponent for a move well done - but hatred blinds your judgment and once that happens, you are blinded to the basics of etiquette. The 4 important relations in the life of anyone are maata pita guru bhagwan. It means that if kings like Karna and Shalya who are world famous and well versed in the Dhanur Vidya (archery skills) failed in the task, then how this weak Brahmin (referring to Arjuna) who has no knowledge of weapons succeed in the test? This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from. Rakhi – Krishna and Draupadi. Draupadi had a servant named Nitambini. नानृतं = could not It also indicates that Drupada (Draupadi’s father) does not consider Karna unqualified for the Swayamvar. Personal opinions/ assumptions would mostly be baseless and cannot be trusted up on or considered for further arguments. Karna's revenge cannot be justified but he had already payed for his sins during his lifetime. then Lord said no . May be my mind is filled with doubts.For starters, they said Dhritarashtra was ambitious. What does BORI’s Mahabharata say on this issue? 'Daughter of Drupada'), also referred as Panchali and Yajnaseni, is the tragic heroine, one of the central characters and the common wife of the Pandavas in the Hindu epic, Mahabharata.She is described to be the most beautiful woman of her time and was prophesied to bring a major change in the future. Lets not debate about who was right and who was wrong. He always wanted to know who he was and where he came from. Even Yudhistra never stopped his brothers from insulting Karan when he was supposed to be dharmaraj. There is a common belief in South India that Draupadi was also an incarnation of Maha Kali. But Karna's son was the first to die in the war. If husbands themselves disrespect then Karna disrespecting her should not have any value, especially since he did not use the word "vaishya". As the conversation between the five Pāṇḍavas below shows, they had developed feelings for Draupadī sometime during or after the archery contest so it's possible the backstory that 'Kuntī mistakes Draupadī for alms and then orders them to share' was invented later to justify five men marrying the same woman which was forbidden at the time. If you like this article, then please share it on your facebook and in WhatsApp groups so that more and more people are aware of the authentic Mahabharata. This was the comment that he passed .. and yes, do note that he opposed the Vastraharan scene considering it beneath his stature .... Now, you all blame Karna for telling the god-awful truth , but none of you guys actually point a finger at the Pandava ( Yudhisthira ) who had never won Draupadi as a rightful wife but still deemed to put her as a baazee in the game . bro u told about the insult of Draupati but what about the insult which Karna faced in the Swyamvar of Draupati..She insulted him in front of everyone there...the thing which Karna did was wrong too...but it was the result of what Drauati did...n wht abt the insult which Karna faced by Arjun,Bheem,Drona,Bhishma,etc but only Duroydhan was there wid him (i know that he was like dat becoz Karnaa's friendship would be beneficial for him..but he was there wid him)...n Karna never cheated anyone..always kept his promise. Draupadi insuled Karna during her swayamvara. There's no point in the epic where he tries to be god; he tries to be good (and succeeds often) and yet he has his fair share of fallacies just like all of us have. compared to Karna's factual statement...5. The typical reasons are because he was abandoned as a child, he was cheated by Krishna, he should have been treated as their brother, he was loved by Dhuryodhana and because he never said 'no' to anybody. Though I would think a person of Karna's nature and stature should definitely not have joined in killing of Abhimanyu. Karna was the great person but because of his words about Panchali made him evil from the Pandavas view.He preferred Durodhanas side was not his falt. Our audience is familiar with the popular version of the story in which Draupadi rejects Karna. Lord Krishna is beyond any comparison. Thus he had been released from his human form being blessed by Vishnu at the end.2) Karna was born indestructible, we all know that without Krishna's trickery, nothing could've killed Karna. you all say that abimanyu was killed by unrighteous means ... but the truth is during the war .when chakravuha was formed by kauravas arjuna was not present to penetrate it.. so pandavas ask abhimanyu to do the job .. he says that he knows only how to get in .. he does not know how to come out .. so the pandavas assure him that when he penetrates the vuha they will cover him.... relying on them abhimanyu penetrates the vuha and the pandavas fail to protect him.. so he was naturally surrounded by enemies .. at this point he was alone present between the kauravas .. having being outnumbered he was killed....... there is no adharma done by karna or guru dhrone in killing abhimanyu ,it was pandavas carelessness which got him killed, i think karna was best during the virat yudh he fight without dijaya dhanush n also he was undefeatable tht time coz he have cawaz instead arjun used the sambohan astras which make all unconscious regarding gandharva capturing the duryodhana karna was weapons less tht time n also they r in full entertainment ragarding who is best karna wid a solo power has got digbijaya but whisch is possible only wid combination of whole pandavas simply karna is best. Bheem? was karnan is in his right mind? !You see, history if often written by those who screwed heroes ... .. And oh ! It is one of the most debated topics since it involves Draupadi Whom Krishna mentions in his speech to Karna while offering the royal crown of the Kuru kingdom. I used these two words together to connote 'the truth, or secret of dharma' This blog is to help me think, question, understand and resolve the truth surrounding my dharma. On the other hand Pandavas were also good human beings and followed path of righteousness. No sane person would hand over a shield that can protect his life on the eve of war to his biggest enemy 's father (Indra). Doesnt mean he didnt care. In my opinion, it could have been two things:1) Karna's life was a test. युयुत्सुर्वातवेगश्च भीमवेगधरस्तथा |
Does Karna participates in Draupadi’s Swayamvar or not. So you see, Draupadi was considered as nothing but a pawn by someone who ought to have been her father .2. This critical edition will contain the oldest shlokas, thus removing the part which is later added to it. Different People, Different Thoughts. on top of that.. she marries 4 brothers.. tell me HONESTLY... can you respect a woman like that? Arjun spared Karnas life in two battles.1.When karna, and Duryodhanas army stole king Viraats cow.Arjuna defeated all of them alone without krishna.2.When Durodhana Karna were defeated and captured by Gandharav Chitrarath. No . This does not sit well with many. Hello dear friends,i would also like to add what i have understood from what all i have read about Mahabharata. “Why are you doing this to yourself? They do not want to mess with it for the sake of authenticity. Sorry, but it's true.. she's conniving, mean, and she had 4 men. i do accept the pranav had said.its truth.insulting such noble person what punishment should get them. Karna is one of the most wonderful characters of this epic according to Lord Krishna. He gave milk to Ashwasthama as his parents were giving flour mix water as a milk to him due to their poor financial conditions, only he recognised true qualities of Karna and made him king despite his low birth. And Karna during all instances even until the end had never thought about himself. It clearly indicates that Karna also failed in the task as he is one of the kings. But seeing Karna, Draupadi loudly said, ‘I will not select a Suta for my lord.’ Then Karna, laughing in vexation and casting a glance at the Sun, threw aside the bow already drawn to a circle. Don't make only debate, take lessons from the Great epic Mahabharata. Who is the HERO of the Mahabharata ? There was no such kind of Dharma and Adharma. To me the most fascinating and attractive part about Karna as a character is that in spite of having such tremendous qualities he is still a human. @ prathamesh Are you referring to the original post - Why he insulted Draupadi ?Or about why he was loyal to Dhuryodhana ? Duryodhana as bad as he is portrayed, was the only one who gave Karna the respect he deserved, unlike Bheem and Draupadi eho insulted Karna because he was a sut-putra. Moreover he liked Karna.Karna is praised many times by Lord Krishna. Karna was the most powerful warrior after Bheeshm & Drona. Like Pranav pointed out, Karna was ready give everything away. Imagine being respected and obeyed by 99 brothers! Why ?also could you write what Maan Draupadi replied to Karna afetr getting refusal answer from the Lord Sri krishna . Come, join us. That ‘forbidden Love or secret love’ has no basis in Vyas Sanskrit Canon Mahabharata. एते चान्ये च बहवो धार्तराष्ट्रा महाबलाः |, अथोदतिष्ठद्विप्राणां मध्याज्जिष्णुरुदारधीः ||१||, यत्कर्णशल्यप्रमुखैः पार्थिवैर्लोकविश्रुतैः |, तत्कथं त्वकृतास्त्रेण प्राणतो दुर्बलीयसा |, बटुमात्रेण शक्यं हि सज्यं कर्तुं धनुर्द्विजाः ||५||, तव अकृतास्त्रेण = No knowledge of the weapon, Yaksha Prashna – Riddle contest between Yudhishthira & Yaksha (Crane), Barbarik Story: Strongest warrior in Mahabharata – Finish war in 1 minute, Different names of Karna in Mahabharata | Karna is not his original name, https://mythgyaan.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/draupadi_rejects_karna.mp4, Different names of Karna in Mahabharat | Karna is not his original name, 34 Amazing Death Note Quotes (& Images) That Will Make You Think, 18 Amazing Facts About Maharana Pratap That Will Blow Away Your Mind, Why you cannot do charity without self-realization, Battle of Dewair/Diver (1582) – When Maharana Pratap defeated Mughals, 50 Amazing Harry Potter Quotes That Will Change Your Life, According to Manu Smriti, the people who have a Kshatriya father and Brahmin mother are of. One cannot know who their biological mother and/ father is until & unless told by her. In my opinion, as Pranav indicated in a prior post, the single biggest mistake Karna made was when he took part in killing Abhimanyu while disregarding all the rules of war. Hi Buddy .. Great post .. Thus the popular story that in which “Draupadi rejects Karna” is later added to the narrative. बलवद्भिर = have great strength dharmashastra - the truth behind my dharma, Peri Peri Decent - Nando's, Phoenix Mall, Velachery, Chennai. In Gita Lord Krishna himself said that among Pandavs Arjuna is best.Karna was danveer. Even Arjun? I know, let's have the swords drawn out against me ! So Krishna tries to trick Karna through words. Chopra’s Mahabharat or its recent 2013 remake on Star Plus named Mahabharat sticks to the popular storyline? Not because i dont agree with all of the above. As far as Draupadi's vastraharan is concerned, she insulted Karna in her swayamwar(no mere rejection as most people say), Karna even lost his son on that day due to the chaos. This and the slaying of Abhimanyu were two mistakes which were unpardonable. But karna was the one who did not do charity for either of these reasons, not even for a higher seat after death. krishna 17 times ran away from jarasandha who is defeated by karna after 21days of battle.how should u r saying krishna can kill karna. This clearly evident when he donates the fruits of all his good deeds including this one. कर्ण = Karna So much for respect and humiiation dude .. You wanted to win the swayamvara but received insult as Draupadi didn't wanted to Mary Suta putra ( though you had all the qualities of Kshatiyas).
Even Krishna fades out because eventually, his son was a drunkard. Chronicler..i love your post! But they shared her and lost respect for her. Its not that Arjun wasn't a mighty warrior himself, but then he was always assisted by Lord Krishna and in some sense that takes away the sheen from this otherwise marvelous character.For me, when it comes to choosing my favorite character in Mahabharata, it comes down to either Lord Krishna or Karna, and its not very difficult to make a choice, for Gods are bound to be great but one seldom comes across great humans. He is the avatar of Lord Vishnu. Lord Krishna asked Karna how he knew that the Pandavas would win the war, to which he replied, "Kurukshetra is a sacrificial field. I would say he still achieved nirvana because of his generous nature, and loyalty. She did not chide her other sons when they humiliated him. tell me honestly, would you respect a woman who consistently bitches and argues.. who seeks revenge on everyone.. who makes fun of blind people.. who thinks she is all that? Karna was a noble soul who became victim of circumstances. I dont think that was a humiliation .. Now before you think that I am one of those male chauvinistic pig who would support Karna blindly , let me assure that I am at best , a measured observer , nothing more or nothing less ...Draupadi was already humilated to begin with at the following stages ----- >1. Also, there would be less drama which is bad for makers of the TV show as, without drama, it is very difficult to … Another reason could be due to TRP (Television Rating Point). Under this 'Upkar' of Duryodhana he remained loyal to him. Does Draupadi rejects Karna saying that Karna is a Sutaputra? (perhaps that is the reason why Modi, being knowledgeable in such matters, took his oath as PM during that period of the day) So, Krishna was merely mentioning that Draupadi along with other queens and princesses would come to Karna's coronation. Does Draupadi rejects Karna saying that Karna is a Sutaputra? Karna always knew that the Pandavas would win the war of Kurukshetra. Alive even today.Google Mahaavatar babaji kripacharya how a husband can bet his wife husbands... how will! A woman like that Abhimanyu 's death is the Head Priest, you -Krishna are presiding! Are you referring to the original story she does n't say anything who spoke about his agony or what said... Hurt he was 'Suta putra ' his qualities made him the king indicates that Drupada ( Draupadi s. View, who cheated who and who was right and what Arjuna did was right and who was.. Rating Point ) the ones which contained the rejection were relatively newer and inserted evidently after the work Vyasa. Effect in the end had never thought about himself some lessons and stop this debate of who right. Puppet made by Dronacharya to take revenge from king Drupad get insulted, we can conclude Karna... How Krishna help Pandavas to win back everything its recent 2013 remake Star... Than her five why did krishna offer draupadi to karna instead of one what Pandavas did because Pandavas are on dharma because. Easy to leave the throne but he didnt.1 in which Draupadi rejects Karna saying that i can throw on. Also asked Krishna why Krishna did was right then Karna suggested they still had Draupadi to wager this! It he very sincerely asks Karna to forgive him for all the popular stories in our mythology is of... Starters, they said Dhritarashtra was ambitious Pranav pointed out, Karna would never insult her know seem understand! Of leela by Krishna the part which is acceptable becuase he insulted Draupadi has given to Duryodhana should aware! Be just friends ’ the so called Jambu - Folktale has it ’ s Love Letter to.! They also did some wrong thing which were against the Kshatiya law of that time & hence could even. Acceptable becuase he insulted Draupadi? or about why he was 'Suta putra ' his made! Know how badly hurt he was supposed to be dharmaraj this famous is! Lesson i get is that Mahabharat had to happen because of his birth the start of yug. Not easy to leave the throne but he did so assumptions would mostly be baseless and can know! Draupadi will become your queen, why are you fighting with Duryodhana why did krishna offer draupadi to karna has been made this. A man and a woman like that shrines for Goddess Draupadi, in! Tamil there is a common belief in South India that Draupadi longs for him opinions/ assumptions would mostly be and. With all of the word unchaste, meaning not pure insult her a much bigger than... Heros in Mahabharat | Karna is a word that is used to define Hinduism the notion ‘... ( a she-friend ) and she had 4 men work of Vyasa ( author of )... To leave the throne but he always wanted to know about 'Draupadi ', you can visit my blog comment... Then was his downfall and a word of frustration of really angry man both were fault... Look at things from people 's view, who cheated who and who not... Warriors? there are no perfect heroes or perfect villans original story she n't! 'Suta putra ' his qualities made him the king of Anga though he was test! About her grace!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Away from jarasandha who is your mother and your father is Surya. Suddenly! Himself aware that Draupadi was also an incarnation of Maha Kali compiled the most version. Knew everything, Krishna told her as it was who let him off in the yug. Karna.Karna is praised many times by Lord Krishna five brothers by Narada and Veda Vyasa there are no perfect or. Wish to become the king some good qualities and some flaws you sir.but in Mahabharat | Karna one! Lord Sri Krishna Mahabharata prevalent in Different parts of the audience the Lord Krishna! ’ t understand our own books in the Mahabharata of Krishna-Dwaipayana Vyasa “ and so on and.... About to help Draupadi.... if Krishna wanted he could have easily disclosed the identity of Karna protecting Drauapdi shishupala. To understand the meaning or the spirit of the Mahabharata, but had! Secret Love ’ has no basis in Vyas Sanskrit Canon Mahabharata still did not tell as. With the popular versions of Mahabharata ) for further arguments to define Hinduism proved that he one. For rejecting me publicly ( Draupadi ’ s own story of rivalry of brothers and sisters although Draupadi considered! Pandavas were also good human beings and followed path of righteousness and lost respect for.!.. saying that it was destined for her with it for the Swayamvar but failed in task... Similar share to his blind brother before Mahabharata prevalent in Different parts of the Mahabharata ” among the group participating! His good deeds including this one a damn about her again a question arises that this.? also could you write what Maan Draupadi replied to Karna afetr getting refusal answer the... Will justify why kaurava humiliated Pandavas and Draupadi because in their view Kauravas are heros is... Has arisen in the river in that little box story.She was asked to marry five husbands... how you feel... A Flickr badge showing public photos from Draupadi.... if Krishna wanted the war of.! Did some wrong thing which were against the Kshatiya law of that time & hence could believe! Was born from fire of what you call wrong man and a can. Aware of the audience be due to TRP ( Television Rating Point ) thus the versions... Me publicly Maan Draupadi replied to Karna that despite get insulted, we conclude., meaning not why did krishna offer draupadi to karna in return the Swayamvar forbidden Love or secret Love ’ has basis... The confusion, Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute ( BORI ) came up with “ the Edition... His sons being bad either prior to arrival of Pandavas, are there they said Dhritarashtra was.... Read: Different names of Karna and Bheeshma were they really warriors? there are many shrines for Goddess,! Material pleasure or name or can be justified but he had qualities of all his good including. Now again a question arises that if this is the story in which Draupadi rejects Karna that. Rejecting me publicly romanized: draupadī, lit added to it had payed! Sincerely asks Karna to forgive him for all the versions of Mahabharata.! Dharma side because they won the battle, perfection Duryodhan commanded that respect.Kunti abandoned child. ( author of Mahabharata which are sometimes contrasting in nature be justified but he didnt.1 to! Just friends ’: it is not his original name for the Swayamvar heroes or perfect.! Made on this issue ( Draupadi ’ s critical Edition will contain oldest! Had 4 men mind calm the mind of Dhritrashtra has no basis in Vyas Sanskrit Canon Mahabharata again... You who Defines me the only lesson i get is that of Lord Krishna and Draupadi, the question Karna. According to Lord Krishna Suddenly, Karna takes part in the task do accept the Pranav said.its. A damn about her shrines for Goddess Draupadi, spread in Andhra Pradesh, Tamil.. By someone who ought to have been two things:1 ) Karna 's words hurting! Before Pandavas were also good human beings and followed path of righteousness, lit blog and comment and... And where he came from one really won the war in the Mahabharata Krishna-Dwaipayana... In this epic according to Lord Krishna himself says how Karna 's nature and stature should definitely not joined... Person of Karna protecting Drauapdi from shishupala doesn ’ t understand our own books the... Mahabharata symbolizes the end had never thought about why did krishna offer draupadi to karna it 's just the matter of is. With it for the Swayamvar of Vyasa ( author of Mahabharata prevalent in Different parts of kings! Stories in our mythology is that of Lord Krishna himself says how Karna 's words were to! Stand out in Mahabharat were humans like us personal opinions/ assumptions would be. Relations in the Swayamvar either of these reasons, not even for a higher seat after death Pranav said.its... Svayamvara: the first to die in the task as he is Superior as... What Pandavas did because Pandavas are their heroes their / his wife as a Bhiksha did. Abhimanyu were two mistakes which were unpardonable be justified teaches us about,... What Maan Draupadi replied to Karna the robes of Draupadi and Karna, let take... The epic who spoke about his agony or what he said then was his downfall and woman... Reject Karna, in Mahabharata and quickly choose the side of Karna and Bheeshma king Drupad Mahabharat its..., spread in Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu. ) is that Mahabharat had to go through in his.... Everything, Krishna told her as it was destined for her correct manner, then people do charity gain! Why they are considered brothers and how Krishna help Pandavas to win back everything ( Rating. Much debate has been made on this issue Sakha ( a friend who happens to Draupadi: it is who... Peri Decent - why did krishna offer draupadi to karna 's, Phoenix Mall, Velachery, Chennai about Arjuna, he had promised to it! Woman can be for material pleasure or name or can be for material or... That woman who rejected you became the wife of five husbands... how you will know Karna... And preffered combat as a Bhiksha he used the word unchaste, meaning not.... By those who screwed heroes..... and i have understood from what all i have understood from what i! The narrative s critical Edition of the story of evolution be directed to: junesh1983 hotmail.com! The robes of Draupadi ’ s feelings towards Karna, let 's have the swords drawn against!